The most warning signs

Judges whose pages show the most of the ten due process warning signs: time to prepare refused, continuances cut since January 20, 2025, the government favored on the same kind of request, the person’s own motions denied, asylum ended without a hearing, asylum rarely granted, fast denials, and bonds set high, set very high or rarely granted. A count, ranked as it stands; ties go to the larger asylum docket. The arrow beside each sign on a judge’s page explains how it is counted.

#JudgeCourtAppointed underAsylum decisionsGrantedWarning signs
1Kenya WellsHouston — Greenspoint Park, TXJoe Biden962248 of 10
2Carrie C Johnson-PapilloNew York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump1,3302347 of 10
3Jerome M. Rothschild Jr. (former judge)Santa Ana, CADonald Trump1,1991967 of 10
4Mary C BaumgartenBuffalo, NYDonald Trump1,0241147 of 10
5Karen NazaireNew York — Federal Plaza, NYJoe Biden813517 of 10
6Justin DinsdaleHouston — Greenspoint Park, TXJoe Biden707137 of 10
7Alexander RubinBuffalo, NYDonald Trump4907 of 10
8Jennifer ChungNew York — Broadway, NYDonald Trump1,7675456 of 10
9Blake DoughtyAtlanta — W. Peachtree Street, GADonald Trump1,2241096 of 10
10Carol MooreNew York — Broadway, NYJoe Biden1,0902296 of 10
11Thomas AyzeMiami, FLDonald Trump1,0231086 of 10
12Kevin BrownHouston — S. Gessner Road, TXDonald Trump990316 of 10
13Danielle H GartenHouston — Greenspoint Park, TXJoe Biden45726 of 10
14Jennifer M Riedthaler-WilliamsCleveland, OHDonald Trump452606 of 10
15Maithe GonzalezJena, LAJoe Biden225256 of 10
16Richard J DouglasDallas, TXDonald Trump19406 of 10
17Robert McBrideAtlanta — W. Peachtree Street, GADonald Trump7506 of 10
18Jonathan Charles AndresenHouston — S. Gessner Road, TXDonald Trump7106 of 10
19Brandon KennedyCleveland, OHDonald Trump6416 of 10
20Melissa I IsaakLumpkin, GADonald Trump5816 of 10
21Peter T McCaryElizabeth, NJDonald Trump2216 of 10
22William RichardsJena, LADonald Trump2006 of 10
23Matthew DavidhizarTacoma, WADonald Trump506 of 10
24Maria I AkalskiNewark, NJJoe Biden2,410985 of 10
25Kuyomars Q GolparvarBaltimore, MDBarack Obama1,2511565 of 10
26Daniel B ConklinIndianapolis, INJoe Biden1,0501065 of 10
27Jennifer WinfieldDallas, TXJoe Biden1,009915 of 10
28Valerie A BurchIndianapolis, INBarack Obama9791305 of 10
29Maritza S RamosHouston, TXJoe Biden976755 of 10
30Joshua D OsbornHouston — Greenspoint Park, TXDonald Trump947795 of 10
31Ryan FisherAtlanta — W. Peachtree Street, GADonald Trump927455 of 10
32Timothy M ColeConroe, TXBarack Obama8541365 of 10
33Steven MarcusVan Nuys, CADonald Trump8361645 of 10
34Jane Chace MillerIndianapolis, INJoe Biden78845 of 10
35Robert M LewandowskiCharlotte, NCDonald Trump781535 of 10
36Mark J JebsonDetroit, MIBarack Obama7461055 of 10
37Brent H Landis (former judge)Houston — Greenspoint Park, TXDonald Trump740335 of 10
38Jason L SternHouston — Greenspoint Park, TXJoe Biden730295 of 10
39Carey R HollidayBaton Rouge, LADonald Trump68005 of 10
40Oshea SpencerHouston — Greenspoint Park, TXDonald Trump663205 of 10
41Tamar H WilsonNewark, NJDonald Trump6601045 of 10
42Irma J NewburnMemphis, TNJoe Biden567555 of 10
43Ellen KareshCharlotte, NCJoe Biden554685 of 10
44Tara Naselow-NahasDallas, TXBarack Obama531235 of 10
45Stuart A SiegelMiami — Krome, FLBarack Obama525395 of 10
46Olga E AttiaSan Diego, CADonald Trump481625 of 10
47Philip P TaylorAtlanta — W. Peachtree Street, GADonald Trump471295 of 10
48Madeline GarciaMiami, FLBarack Obama447555 of 10
49Miguel A Cordero GonzalezHouston — S. Gessner Road, TXDonald Trump400215 of 10
50Juan RomanOmaha, NEDonald Trump20225 of 10

Decisions from 2021 through 10/01/2026. Showing 50 of 893 that qualified. Past patterns, not predictions — every case turns on its own facts and law.