EOIR Insights

Buffalo, NY Immigration Court

12 judges with decisions since 2021 · Court asylum grant rate 25.7% (3,850 decisions)

About this page
What is EOIR? The Executive Office for Immigration Review — the Justice Department agency that runs the nation's immigration courts and their appellate body, the Board of Immigration Appeals. More about EOIR
Read this first. These are past decisions, not predictions, and not a tool for choosing or avoiding a judge. How to read these figures

Buffalo, NY Immigration Court

12 judges with decisions since 2021 · Court asylum grant rate 25.7% (3,850 decisions)
Judges (most asylum decisions first)
Mary C BaumgartenBuffalo, NYAppointed March 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG Matthew Whitaker
11.1%asylum · 1,024 decisions
Walter H RuehleNo longer at courtBuffalo, NYAppointed September 2016 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
43%asylum · 740 decisions
Steven J ConnellyNo longer at courtBuffalo, NYAppointed October 2010 · President Barack Obama → AG Eric H. Holder Jr.
32.3%asylum · 501 decisions
Denise HochulNo longer at courtBuffalo, NYAppointed January 2016 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
55.2%asylum · 420 decisions
Brandi LohrBuffalo, NYAppointed August 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
20%asylum · 406 decisions
Robert DriscollBuffalo, NYAppointed October 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
16.6%asylum · 296 decisions
Eric SchultzBuffalo, NYAppointed December 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
6.7%asylum · 195 decisions
Brian CounihanBuffalo, NYAppointed February 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
10.4%asylum · 134 decisions
Alexander RubinBuffalo, NYAppointed July 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
0%asylum · 49 decisionsLow sample: 49 decisions
Susan F AikmanNo longer at courtBuffalo, NYAppointed January 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
14.3%asylum · 42 decisionsLow sample: 42 decisions
Christopher StaszakBuffalo, NYAppointed June 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
0%asylum · 40 decisionsLow sample: 40 decisions
Brandon JarochFired · February 14, 2025Buffalo, NYAppointed October 2021 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
0%asylum · 3 decisionsLow sample: 3 decisions