EOIR Insights

New York — Federal Plaza, NY Immigration Court

65 judges with decisions since 2021 · Court asylum grant rate 48% (40,856 decisions)

About this page
What is EOIR? The Executive Office for Immigration Review — the Justice Department agency that runs the nation's immigration courts and their appellate body, the Board of Immigration Appeals. More about EOIR
Read this first. These are past decisions, not predictions, and not a tool for choosing or avoiding a judge. How to read these figures

New York — Federal Plaza, NY Immigration Court

65 judges with decisions since 2021 · Court asylum grant rate 48% (40,856 decisions)
Judges (most asylum decisions first)
Tiesha PealNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
11%asylum · 2,076 decisions
Deborah E KlahrNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
28.2%asylum · 2,026 decisions
Anna C LittleNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG Matthew Whitaker
43.2%asylum · 1,951 decisions
Cathy SagesseNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
39.5%asylum · 1,574 decisions
Dania NassarNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
28.6%asylum · 1,491 decisions
Virna A WrightNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2010 · President Barack Obama → AG Eric H. Holder Jr.
38.1%asylum · 1,467 decisions
Scott ThomsenNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
44.9%asylum · 1,373 decisions
Donald W. Thompson Jr.No longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed April 2017 · President Donald Trump → AG Jeff Sessions
56.7%asylum · 1,363 decisions
Carrie C Johnson-PapilloNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG Matthew Whitaker
17.6%asylum · 1,330 decisions
Barbara A NelsonNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 1995 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
32.4%asylum · 1,297 decisions
Dorothy A HarbeckNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 2006 · President George W. Bush → AG Alberto Gonzales
50.9%asylum · 1,292 decisions
Michael G McfarlandNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed August 2018 · President Donald Trump → AG Jeff Sessions
59.5%asylum · 1,140 decisions
John SiemietkowskiNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed January 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
26.7%asylum · 1,130 decisions
Kyle DandeletFired · May 21, 2026New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
58.1%asylum · 1,080 decisions
Randa ZagzougNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed May 2010 · President Barack Obama → AG Eric H. Holder Jr.
80.4%asylum · 992 decisions
Carol A CrawfordNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed December 2021 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
41.2%asylum · 972 decisions
Evalyn P DouchyFired · December 1, 2025New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2016 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
79.2%asylum · 965 decisions
Amanda JeannopoulosNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed June 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
43%asylum · 945 decisions
Jonathan ReingoldNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
30.2%asylum · 931 decisions
Gioia MaiellanoNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed December 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
23.4%asylum · 895 decisions
Theodora N KourisFired · December 1, 2025New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
80.9%asylum · 871 decisions
Lena GolovninNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed August 2018 · President Donald Trump → AG Jeff Sessions
50.5%asylum · 864 decisions
Jem C SponzoFired · May 21, 2026New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed February 2017 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
64.4%asylum · 859 decisions
William McdermottNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed May 2021 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
55.4%asylum · 849 decisions
Alice SegalFired · December 1, 2025New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2010 · President Barack Obama → AG Eric H. Holder Jr.
78.3%asylum · 830 decisions
Samuel M FactorNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 2018 · President Donald Trump → AG Jeff Sessions
41.4%asylum · 828 decisions
Frederic G LeedsNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2006 · President George W. Bush → AG Alberto Gonzales
82%asylum · 815 decisions
Karen NazaireNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
6.3%asylum · 813 decisions
Lori AdamsFired · December 1, 2025New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2021 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
81.3%asylum · 796 decisions
Maria LuryeFired · December 1, 2025New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed April 2017 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
85.1%asylum · 778 decisions
F. James Loprest Jr.New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2010 · President Barack Obama → AG Eric H. Holder Jr.
64%asylum · 761 decisions
Vivienne E Gordon-UruakpaNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed June 2002 · President George W. Bush → AG John Ashcroft
88.5%asylum · 695 decisions
Cynthia GordonNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed August 2018 · President Donald Trump → AG Jeff Sessions
76.4%asylum · 666 decisions
Mimi TsankovNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed November 2006 · President George W. Bush → AG Alberto Gonzales
85.5%asylum · 653 decisions
Lisa EhrensFired · December 1, 2025New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
83.8%asylum · 594 decisions
David KimFired · September 2025New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
84.4%asylum · 487 decisions
Amiena A KhanFired · December 1, 2025New York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed December 2010 · President Barack Obama → AG Eric H. Holder Jr.
78.8%asylum · 471 decisions
Raisa CohenNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2016 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
91%asylum · 454 decisions
Linda HristovaNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
3.1%asylum · 290 decisions
Edwin PietersNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed July 2021 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
58.5%asylum · 142 decisions
James KitchenNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed June 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
0.8%asylum · 130 decisions
Jean M KilkerNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
6.7%asylum · 119 decisions
Laurie SamuelsNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed June 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
0%asylum · 104 decisions
Christopher CusmanoNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
2.9%asylum · 103 decisions
Richard HollowayNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
14.3%asylum · 91 decisions
Marion S MishkinNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed June 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
6.8%asylum · 73 decisions
Marla GillmanNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed June 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
1.4%asylum · 70 decisions
Robert MoskowNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed June 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
0%asylum · 66 decisions
Watson BerichNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed June 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
0%asylum · 66 decisions
Toniann TerritolaNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed July 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
8.3%asylum · 48 decisionsLow sample: 48 decisions
Adrien Lee-LoNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
8.9%asylum · 45 decisionsLow sample: 45 decisions
Jennifer HenryNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed July 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
7.9%asylum · 38 decisionsLow sample: 38 decisions
David FraidenNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
83.3%asylum · 36 decisionsLow sample: 36 decisions
Louis J LubaNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed July 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
0%asylum · 33 decisionsLow sample: 33 decisions
Brett GeigerNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed August 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
0%asylum · 14 decisionsLow sample: 14 decisions
Niles GerryNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed August 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
8.3%asylum · 12 decisionsLow sample: 12 decisions
Helen SichelNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed May 1997 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
0%asylum · 1 decisionLow sample: 1 decision
Rantideva SinghNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed January 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
100%asylum · 1 decisionLow sample: 1 decision
Brian J BoydNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
Daniel FellhauerNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
David EricksonNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NY
—no asylum merits
David S LoNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
Jeffrey L MenkinNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG Matthew Whitaker
—no asylum merits
Jesse SchaeferTemporary Immigration JudgeNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
Joanna M BukszpanNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 1995 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
—no asylum merits
John C AllisonNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
Kathy W ParrinoNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
Kevin L HoffmanTemporary Immigration JudgeNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
Margaret McmanusNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed January 1991 · President George H. W. Bush → AG Dick Thornburgh
—no asylum merits
Status Docket JuvenileDocket code, not a judge New York — Federal Plaza, NY
9decisions recorded
Terry A BainNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed February 1994 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
—no asylum merits
William IrvineNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed October 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
William Van WykeNo longer at courtNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed March 1995 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
—no asylum merits
Zachary N GodseyNew York — Federal Plaza, NYAppointed September 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits