EOIR Insights

New York — Broadway, NY Immigration Court

34 judges with decisions since 2021 · Court asylum grant rate 31.8% (26,324 decisions)

About this page
What is EOIR? The Executive Office for Immigration Review — the Justice Department agency that runs the nation's immigration courts and their appellate body, the Board of Immigration Appeals. More about EOIR
Read this first. These are past decisions, not predictions, and not a tool for choosing or avoiding a judge. How to read these figures

New York — Broadway, NY Immigration Court

34 judges with decisions since 2021 · Court asylum grant rate 31.8% (26,324 decisions)
Judges (most asylum decisions first)
Shirley Lazare-RaphaelNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed December 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
22.6%asylum · 1,905 decisions
Jennifer ChungNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed January 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
30.8%asylum · 1,767 decisions
Jesse B ChristensenNo longer at courtNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed October 2010 · President Barack Obama → AG Eric H. Holder Jr.
14.9%asylum · 1,753 decisions
John BurnsNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed December 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
2%asylum · 1,719 decisions
Adam PerlNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed April 2021 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
16.7%asylum · 1,636 decisions
Robert GundlachNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed March 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
39.6%asylum · 1,378 decisions
James MckeeNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed October 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
11.3%asylum · 1,286 decisions
Andrew CalvelliNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed March 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
47.6%asylum · 1,131 decisions
Carol MooreNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed October 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
21%asylum · 1,090 decisions
Michael LloydNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed June 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
23.9%asylum · 1,087 decisions
James M MccarthyNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed July 2017 · President Donald Trump → AG Jeff Sessions
38.5%asylum · 971 decisions
Thomas BartlesonNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed June 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
55.8%asylum · 957 decisions
Carolyn KrasinskiNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed March 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
33.1%asylum · 919 decisions
Aviva L PoczterNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed December 2010 · President Barack Obama → AG Eric H. Holder Jr.
40.4%asylum · 891 decisions
Tanawa LebretonNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed October 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
40.6%asylum · 724 decisions
Kalenna LeeNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed May 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
26.6%asylum · 719 decisions
Brigitte LaforestNo longer at courtNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed April 1997 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
53%asylum · 624 decisions
Olivia L CassinFired · November 24, 2025New York — Broadway, NYAppointed June 2015 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
86.9%asylum · 580 decisions
Maria E NavarroNo longer at courtNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed August 2017 · President Donald Trump → AG Jeff Sessions
70.1%asylum · 568 decisions
Anna DiaoNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed November 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
22.6%asylum · 567 decisions
Noel A BrennanNo longer at courtNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed August 2003 · President George W. Bush → AG John Ashcroft
87.9%asylum · 547 decisions
Fayaz HabibNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed May 2024 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
16.9%asylum · 503 decisions
ShaSha XuNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed August 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
17.1%asylum · 480 decisions
Diane DoddNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed January 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
23.8%asylum · 479 decisions
Douglas B SchoppertNo longer at courtNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed May 1997 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
82.9%asylum · 404 decisions
Dianna Michelle Martinez SolerNo longer at courtNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed November 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
58.8%asylum · 398 decisions
Edward GroganNo longer at courtNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed October 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
45.8%asylum · 389 decisions
Chevone Teranza SanonNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed November 2024 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
31.8%asylum · 355 decisions
Khalilah TaylorNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed March 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
36.3%asylum · 146 decisions
Thomas WeisertNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
1.7%asylum · 118 decisions
Christopher StephensNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed April 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
17.4%asylum · 115 decisions
Clayton LawrenceNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
1.4%asylum · 71 decisions
Jacob WeintraubNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed March 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
8.7%asylum · 46 decisionsLow sample: 46 decisions
Yaniris UrracaNo longer at courtNew York — Broadway, NY
0%asylum · 1 decisionLow sample: 1 decision
Anthony BaileyNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed October 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
Clark PetschekNew York — Broadway, NYAppointed October 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits