Most asylum granted by a Republican appointee

Total grants — not a rate — among judges appointed under a Republican administration. The list exists because appointing party is a weak predictor of how a judge decides, and this is what that looks like in the records.

#JudgeCourtAsylum decisionsAsylum granted
1Amber D George (fired 2025-11)San Francisco, CA1,1951,079
2Christopher M GreerWest Valley, UT1,9401,028
3Lisa W LingNew York — Varick Street, NY2,9251,027
4Susan PhanSacramento, CA1,605912
5Anna C LittleNew York — Federal Plaza, NY1,951843
6Jeremy J Butler (former judge)Concord, CA1,206838
7David C AndersonWest Valley, UT1,318826
8David C Koelsch (former judge)Hyattsville, MD1,213804
9Donald W. Thompson Jr. (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NY1,363773
10Justin M Price (former judge)Concord, CA894709
11Robert B.C Mcseveney (former judge)Seattle, WA2,098706
12Theodora N Kouris (fired 2025-12)New York — Federal Plaza, NY871705
13Michael G McfarlandNew York — Federal Plaza, NY1,140678
14Jeremiah Johnson (fired 2025-11)San Francisco, CA782673
15Frederic G Leeds (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NY815668
16Dorothy A HarbeckNew York — Federal Plaza, NY1,292657
17Cathy SagesseNew York — Federal Plaza, NY1,574622
18Scott ThomsenNew York — Federal Plaza, NY1,373617
19Vivienne E Gordon-Uruakpa (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NY695615
20Deborah E KlahrNew York — Federal Plaza, NY2,026572
21Mimi Tsankov (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NY653558
22Shayne R BurnhamNew York — Varick Street, NY1,734552
23Hayden E WindrowSeattle, WA1,936546
24Jennifer ChungNew York — Broadway, NY1,767545
25Robert GundlachNew York — Broadway, NY1,378545
26Richard DruckerCleveland, OH1,729541
27Andrew CalvelliNew York — Broadway, NY1,131538
28Thomas BartlesonNew York — Broadway, NY957534
29Brett M ParchertSeattle, WA1,884533
30Patrick S O'Brien (pressured to retire 2025-12)San Francisco, CA1,127532
31Cynthia Gordon (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NY666509
32Mary C LeePhiladelphia, PA1,510504
33Lisa Ehrens (fired 2025-12)New York — Federal Plaza, NY594498
34Dinesh C VermaHyattsville, MD1,139487
35Noel A Brennan (former judge)New York — Broadway, NY547481
36David M JonesHyattsville, MD1,123479
37Scott D Gambill (former judge)San Francisco, CA658472
38Ann M McdermottLas Vegas, NV897468
39Thomas Mungoven (former judge)New York — Varick Street, NY993468
40Lorianne CampanellaAnnandale (WAS), VA1,465467
41Samia NaseemChicago, IL908458
42Lena GolovninNew York — Federal Plaza, NY864436
43Todd A MastersBoston, MA1,233431
44Shirley Lazare-RaphaelNew York — Broadway, NY1,905431
45Nelson A Vargas-PadillaBaltimore, MD1,130428
46Joseph Y Park (pressured to retire 2025-12)San Francisco, CA721426
47Anita L SimonsLos Angeles — West, CA1,411422
48Patrick M MckennaChicago, IL1,194422
49Brock E TaylorOtero, NM911420
50Lindsy M RobertsLas Vegas, NV694415

Decisions from 2021 through 10/01/2026. Showing 50 of 522 that qualified. Past patterns, not predictions — every case turns on its own facts and law.