EOIR Insights

Philadelphia, PA Immigration Court

20 judges with decisions since 2021 · Court asylum grant rate 34.6% (8,713 decisions)

About this page
What is EOIR? The Executive Office for Immigration Review — the Justice Department agency that runs the nation's immigration courts and their appellate body, the Board of Immigration Appeals. More about EOIR
Read this first. These are past decisions, not predictions, and not a tool for choosing or avoiding a judge. How to read these figures

Philadelphia, PA Immigration Court

20 judges with decisions since 2021 · Court asylum grant rate 34.6% (8,713 decisions)
Judges (most asylum decisions first)
Mary C LeePhiladelphia, PAAppointed May 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
33.4%asylum · 1,510 decisions
John B CarlePhiladelphia, PAAppointed June 2016 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
39.5%asylum · 1,386 decisions
Forrest W. Hoover IIIPhiladelphia, PAAppointed October 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
20.2%asylum · 1,094 decisions
Joseph C ScottPhiladelphia, PAAppointed June 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
32.9%asylum · 1,028 decisions
Antonio CapistranoPhiladelphia, PAAppointed December 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
30%asylum · 912 decisions
Lauren T FarberPhiladelphia, PAAppointed April 2017 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
51.8%asylum · 895 decisions
Dawn KulickPhiladelphia, PAAppointed December 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
40.7%asylum · 442 decisions
Patrick J EhlersNo longer at courtPhiladelphia, PAAppointed October 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
52.5%asylum · 257 decisions
Melissa FoxPhiladelphia, PAAppointed March 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
15.4%asylum · 246 decisions
Mary A FutcherPhiladelphia, PAAppointed May 2024 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
13.1%asylum · 222 decisions
Annie S GarcyNo longer at courtPhiladelphia, PAAppointed March 1990 · President George H. W. Bush → AG Dick Thornburgh
75.3%asylum · 194 decisions
Steven A MorleyNo longer at courtPhiladelphia, PAAppointed December 2010 · President Barack Obama → AG Eric H. Holder Jr.
65.5%asylum · 145 decisions
Keith LipiecPhiladelphia, PAAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
2.2%asylum · 136 decisions
Johanna P GaymerPhiladelphia, PAAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
9.7%asylum · 103 decisions
Devin A WinkloskyPhiladelphia, PAAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
15%asylum · 80 decisions
Rosalind K MalloyNo longer at courtPhiladelphia, PAAppointed December 1998 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
57.1%asylum · 35 decisionsLow sample: 35 decisions
Timothy KellyPhiladelphia, PAAppointed August 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
3.6%asylum · 28 decisionsLow sample: 28 decisions
Charles M HoneymanNo longer at courtPhiladelphia, PAAppointed September 1995 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
—no asylum merits
Joy A MerrimanPhiladelphia, PA
—no asylum merits
Kevin G BradleyNo longer at courtPhiladelphia, PAAppointed March 1997 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
—no asylum merits
Timothy L StrangePhiladelphia, PAAppointed October 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits