EOIR Insights

Chicago, IL Immigration Court

41 judges with decisions since 2021 · Court asylum grant rate 40.2% (15,418 decisions)

About this page
What is EOIR? The Executive Office for Immigration Review — the Justice Department agency that runs the nation's immigration courts and their appellate body, the Board of Immigration Appeals. More about EOIR
Read this first. These are past decisions, not predictions, and not a tool for choosing or avoiding a judge. How to read these figures

Chicago, IL Immigration Court

41 judges with decisions since 2021 · Court asylum grant rate 40.2% (15,418 decisions)
Judges (most asylum decisions first)
Marc StahlChicago, ILAppointed August 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
46.5%asylum · 1,511 decisions
Michael KlosowskyChicago, ILAppointed March 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
28%asylum · 1,248 decisions
Craig A DefoeChicago, ILAppointed March 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG Matthew Whitaker
29.2%asylum · 1,228 decisions
Patrick M MckennaChicago, ILAppointed August 2018 · President Donald Trump → AG Jeff Sessions
35.3%asylum · 1,194 decisions
Samia NaseemChicago, ILAppointed January 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
50.4%asylum · 908 decisions
Gina ReynoldsNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed October 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
60%asylum · 881 decisions
Ana MenciniChicago, ILAppointed October 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
29.2%asylum · 805 decisions
Brendan C CurranChicago, ILAppointed October 2020 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
24.7%asylum · 744 decisions
Elizabeth CritesFired · July 30, 2026Chicago, ILAppointed April 2021 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
49.5%asylum · 730 decisions
Michelle VenciChicago, ILAppointed August 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
25.6%asylum · 672 decisions
Joshua D LuskinChicago, ILAppointed October 2019 · President Donald Trump → AG William P. Barr
39.4%asylum · 640 decisions
Eva S SaltzmanFired · July 30, 2026Chicago, ILAppointed August 2016 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
61.3%asylum · 561 decisions
Elizabeth TreacyResigned · June 22, 2026Chicago, ILAppointed August 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
48.8%asylum · 523 decisions
Sebastian T PattiNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed October 2018 · President Donald Trump → AG Jeff Sessions
78.8%asylum · 443 decisions
Kaarina SalovaaraNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed August 2018 · President Donald Trump → AG Jeff Sessions
45.3%asylum · 426 decisions
Robin J RoscheNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed April 2016 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
63.4%asylum · 380 decisions
Jody BarillaNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed August 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
43.6%asylum · 360 decisions
Carla EspinozaFired · July 11, 2025Chicago, ILAppointed August 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
54%asylum · 272 decisions
Matthew C BeeseChicago, ILAppointed October 2025 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
5.7%asylum · 247 decisions
Philip FluhrNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed November 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
42.4%asylum · 238 decisions
Shawn J AbrahamChicago, ILAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
0%asylum · 170 decisions
Kenneth FleschChicago, ILAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
4.2%asylum · 168 decisions
Kristi NelsonNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed November 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
40.1%asylum · 157 decisions
Samuel B ColeNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed August 2016 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
18.7%asylum · 150 decisions
Jennifer I PeytonFired · July 3, 2025Chicago, ILAppointed September 2016 · President Barack Obama → AG Loretta E. Lynch
77.2%asylum · 136 decisions
Lori YokoyamaNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed December 2022 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
10.9%asylum · 128 decisions
Eliza KleinNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed September 1994 · President Bill Clinton → AG Janet Reno
79.4%asylum · 107 decisions
Maria Baldini-PoterminNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed May 2023 · President Joe Biden → AG Merrick Garland
51%asylum · 96 decisions
Jaime PoarchChicago, ILAppointed May 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
1.4%asylum · 70 decisions
Akash VyasChicago, ILAppointed March 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
13.3%asylum · 60 decisions
Robbin PerkinsChicago, ILAppointed June 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
0%asylum · 58 decisions
Stephen W HarrellChicago, ILAppointed July 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
17.1%asylum · 35 decisionsLow sample: 35 decisions
Albert CharanzaChicago, ILAppointed July 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Pamela Bondi
8.8%asylum · 34 decisionsLow sample: 34 decisions
Visiting Judge 1Docket code, not a judge Chicago, IL
6,641decisions recorded
Visiting Judge 2Docket code, not a judge Chicago, IL
3,868decisions recorded
Visiting Judge 3Docket code, not a judge Chicago, IL
1,546decisions recorded
Anthony C WilliamsChicago, ILAppointed September 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
IAD JudgeDocket code, not a judge Chicago, IL
35,661decisions recorded
James R FujimotoNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed June 1990 · President George H. W. Bush → AG Dick Thornburgh
—no asylum merits
Jennie L GiambastianiNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed May 2002 · President George W. Bush → AG John Ashcroft
—no asylum merits
Jeremy R ArnChicago, ILAppointed October 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
Robert D VinikoorNo longer at courtChicago, ILAppointed January 1984 · President Ronald Reagan → AG William French Smith
—no asylum merits
Rory McGarryChicago, ILAppointed September 2026 · President Donald Trump → AG Todd Blanche
—no asylum merits
Sheila McnultyRemoved · January 20, 2025Chicago, ILAppointed October 2010 · President Barack Obama → AG Eric H. Holder Jr.
—no asylum merits