The highest asylum grant rates

Judges who granted asylum most often, ranked by the lowest their rate could plausibly be — the same guard against small samples, pointed the other way.

#JudgeCourtAppointed underAsylum decisionsGrantedGrant rate
1Shira M Levine (fired 2025-09)San Francisco, CAJoe Biden1,2081,14294.5%
2Maureen O'Sullivan (former judge)Boston, MABarack Obama89682992.5%
3Ila C Deiss (fired 2025-07)San Francisco, CABarack Obama1,6551,51691.6%
4Print Maggard (former judge)Sacramento, CABarack Obama87579590.9%
5Amber D George (fired 2025-11)San Francisco, CADonald Trump1,1951,07990.3%
6Chloe S Dillon (fired 2025-08)San Francisco, CAJoe Biden68562090.5%
7Samuel Y Kim (former judge)San Francisco, CADonald Trump21119592.4%
8Raisa Cohen (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NYBarack Obama45441391.0%
9Vivienne E Gordon-Uruakpa (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NYGeorge W. Bush69561588.5%
10Noel A Brennan (former judge)New York — Broadway, NYGeorge W. Bush54748187.9%
11Olivia L Cassin (fired 2025-11)New York — Broadway, NYBarack Obama58050486.9%
12Jeremiah Johnson (fired 2025-11)San Francisco, CADonald Trump78267386.1%
13Elisa C Brasil (fired 2025-04)San Francisco, CAJoe Biden27524187.6%
14Shuting Chen (fired 2025-11)San Francisco, CAJoe Biden96082185.5%
15Mimi Tsankov (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NYGeorge W. Bush65355885.5%
16Maria Lurye (fired 2025-12)New York — Federal Plaza, NYBarack Obama77866285.1%
17Jami Vigil (fired 2025-04)San Francisco, CAJoe Biden19016586.8%
18Patrick S Savage (fired 2025-11)San Francisco, CABarack Obama81768583.8%
19David Kim (fired 2025-09)New York — Federal Plaza, NYJoe Biden48741184.4%
20Lisa Ehrens (fired 2025-12)New York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump59449883.8%
21Cynthia M Nunez (former judge)San Francisco, CAJoe Biden867688.4%
22Louis A Gordon (fired 2025-11)San Francisco, CAJoe Biden1,17796381.8%
23Frederic G Leeds (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NYGeorge W. Bush81566882.0%
24Sameer Ahmed (former judge)Chelmsford (CHE), MAJoe Biden39532883.0%
25Douglas B Schoppert (former judge)New York — Broadway, NYBill Clinton40433582.9%
26Lori Adams (fired 2025-12)New York — Federal Plaza, NYJoe Biden79664781.3%
27Theodora N Kouris (fired 2025-12)New York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump87170580.9%
28Thomas J Mulligan (former judge)New York — Varick Street, NYGeorge W. Bush48339481.6%
29Randa Zagzoug (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NYBarack Obama99279880.4%
30Alison E Daw (fired 2025-09)Sacramento, CAJoe Biden39531980.8%
31Justin M Price (former judge)Concord, CADonald Trump89470979.3%
32Evalyn P Douchy (fired 2025-12)New York — Federal Plaza, NYBarack Obama96576479.2%
33Arwen A Swink (fired 2025-12)San Francisco, CABarack Obama84767179.2%
34Loreto Geisse (former judge)Sacramento, CAGeorge W. Bush43534880.0%
35Alice Segal (fired 2025-12)New York — Federal Plaza, NYBarack Obama83065078.3%
36Amiena A Khan (fired 2025-12)New York — Federal Plaza, NYBarack Obama47137178.8%
37Sebastian T Patti (former judge)Chicago, ILDonald Trump44334978.8%
38Charles S Greene III (pressured to retire 2025-12)San Francisco, CABarack Obama84465277.3%
39William David Neumeister (former judge)Sacramento, CABarack Obama69353777.5%
40Denise Hunter (fired 2025-12)Sacramento, CAJoe Biden56043477.5%
41Evan Schultz (former judge)Hyattsville, MDJoe Biden1119182.0%
42Cynthia Gordon (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump66650976.4%
43Howard R Davis (pressured to retire 2025-12)San Francisco, CAJoe Biden55542576.6%
44John Henderson (former judge)Hyattsville, MDDonald Trump222090.9%
45Lawrence O Burman (former judge)Annandale (WAS), VABill Clinton67049874.3%
46Eliza Klein (former judge)Chicago, ILBill Clinton1078579.4%
47Jacqueline J Jackson (former judge)San Francisco, CADonald Trump907280.0%
48Rebecca J Walters (former judge)Annandale (WAS), VAJoe Biden564682.1%
49Claudia Cubas (former judge)Hyattsville, MDJoe Biden51337773.5%
50Jennifer I Peyton (fired 2025-07)Chicago, ILBarack Obama13610577.2%

Decisions from 2021 through 10/01/2026. Showing 50 of 321 that qualified. Past patterns, not predictions — every case turns on its own facts and law.