EOIR Insights

Immigration Judge James M. Mccarthy

New York — Broadway, NY Immigration Court · Sitting judge

About this page
What is EOIR? The Executive Office for Immigration Review — the Justice Department agency that runs the nation's immigration courts and their appellate body, the Board of Immigration Appeals. More about EOIR
Read this first. These are past decisions, not predictions, and not a tool for choosing or avoiding a judge. How to read these figures

Immigration Judge James M. Mccarthy

New York — Broadway, NY Immigration Court · Sitting judge
Appointed July 2017 · President Donald Trump → Attorney General Jeff Sessions
9 years on the immigration bench
Appointed under a Republican administration

Attend this judge's internet-based hearing

EOIR publishes a WebEx link and telephonic access code for each sitting judge. Use these only if you have a hearing scheduled before this judge.

▶ Join by WebEx
Dial 1-415-527-5035Access code: 199 485 1150Telephonic access
Source: EOIR — Find an Immigration Court. Recording an internet-based hearing is prohibited (8 C.F.R. § 1003.28). Respondents without a representative default to in-person hearings.

Check your hearing date

The court's own system has the current date, time and place of your next hearing. Hearings are rescheduled without much notice; check again the week before.

Look up my hearing (A-number) ↗
Call 1-800-898-7180Automated, in English and SpanishHave your A-number ready
Missing a hearing can end in a removal order entered in your absence. If you cannot attend, your lawyer can ask the court to move the date — before the hearing, not after.

Where the court is

New York — Broadway Immigration Court
290 Broadway - 15th Flr
New York, NY 10007

Court phone: (212) 240-4900

Open in Maps ↗
Arrive early: building security and the courtroom check-in take time. Bring photo ID and every notice the court has sent you.

Background

The Honorable Immigration Judge James M Mccarthy earned a Bachelor of Science in 1983 from St. John's University and a Juris Doctor in 1995 from Brooklyn Law School. He served as a senior attorney and deputy chief counsel for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement in New York (2011-2017), as a senior and assistant chief counsel for ICE in Arizona (2004-2011), as an examining attorney for the New York City Department of Investigation (2000-2004), and as an assistant district attorney at the Kings County District Attorney's Office (1995-2000).

This judge in the news

Articles about this judge, and things the judge has written. Each link goes to the original source.
Official announcement

Search reviewed October 16, 2026.

Caseload & process (since 2021)
1,039
Completions per year
5,956 total over 5.7 years
4.4%
Detained at decision
share of cases
21.1 mo
Median time to decision
from case start
26.9%
Ordered removed in absentia
person absent
10.8%
Decisions appealed to BIA
appeal rate
2.3%
Respondents’ appeals sent back or reversed
1 of 44 appeals decided
100%
DHS appeals sent back or reversed
4 of 4 appeals decidedLow sample: 4 appeals decided
1,582
Cases pending now
assigned to this judge, undecided
6 months
Typical wait for next hearing
half the open cases have their next hearing sooner, counting from October 1, 2026, when EOIR's data ends
17 months
Furthest hearing set
the latest next hearing on the calendar: February 29, 2028
2
Hearings per case
median per decided case, master and individual hearings before this judge; 1 in 4 took 3 or more; 3 when the case reached an individual (merits) hearing; 150 of the 4,003 cases had no hearing before this judge on record and count as 0

How this judge's cases ended

Every removal-type proceeding this judge completed since 2021, by how it closed. "Moved to another court" is a change of venue or transfer, not a decision.
Ordered removed
2,343 (40%)
Relief granted
508 (8.6%)
Terminated or dismissed
1,276 (22%)
Voluntary departure
96 (1.6%)
Moved to another court
1,496 (25%)
Administratively closed
180 (3.0%)
65% of the removal orders this judge entered (1,522 of 2,343) were in absentia — the person was not at the hearing. A missed hearing before this judge has usually ended in a removal order, so if you cannot attend, tell the court and your lawyer before the date, not after.
5,927 proceedings. Relief includes asylum, withholding, cancellation, adjustment and other grants.

Due process indicators

Since January 20, 2025. What this judge has done with the requests that decide whether a person gets a fair hearing. Every figure is about this judge alone; none is ranked against colleagues.
What the records show

1 of the 10 warning signs appears in this judge’s logged rulings.

  • Continuance requests from respondents’ lawyers
    Measures whether a person with a lawyer gets time to prepare, gather evidence and pursue relief.
    57% granted (151 of 265). Warning sign if under 33% (fewer than 1 in 3).
    Source: EOIR’s motions table. Motions for a continuance (type CO) filed by the respondent or their representative, with a decision of granted or denied, received since January 20, 2025. Only motions filed while a lawyer was already on the case count (an E-28 notice of appearance dated on or before the motion): a request filed without a lawyer is usually the routine first reset to find one. Motions withdrawn or found moot are left out, and oral requests decided in court are often never logged, so this counts what EOIR recorded, not every request made. Warning sign when fewer than 33% were granted. Under 20 rulings the row carries the low-sample note but is still judged.
  • Continuances before and since January 20, 2025
    Measures whether the judge gives people less time since January 20, 2025 than before.
    86% before, 57% since: down 29 points. Warning sign if down 20 points or more.
    The same continuance motions, with the judge’s grant rate from January 1, 2021 up to January 20, 2025 compared with the rate since. Warning sign when the rate since is 20 points or more below the earlier rate, on the whole-number percentages shown. Judges with no rulings before January 20, 2025, mostly those appointed after it, get a dash. The reason for a drop, a change in the docket or pressure from above, is not in the records; the drop is noted regardless.
  • Same request, different answer: DHS against the respondent’s lawyer
    Measures whether the judge says yes to the government and no to the person on the same kind of request: more time, a late document, an extension, appearing by video or phone, an earlier hearing.
    DHS 79%, respondent 74%: DHS 5 points higher. Warning sign if DHS is 25 points or more higher.
    The kinds of motion both sides file: continuance (CO), accept a late-filed document (MD), extension of time (ET), video (TV) or telephone (TA) appearance, and advance the hearing (EH), since January 20, 2025, granted or denied. DHS’s motions of these kinds are compared with the same kinds filed by the respondent’s lawyer (a lawyer on the case when filed). Change of venue, dismissal, termination and reopening are not part of this comparison. Warning sign when DHS’s grant rate is 25 points or more above the respondent’s. DHS files far fewer of these, so DHS’s side often rests on a few dozen rulings; under 20 on either side the row carries the low-sample note.
  • Respondents’ motions to reopen, reconsider, administratively close, stay removal, suppress evidence or go on the status docket
    Measures whether the judge gives the person’s own motions a real chance.
    35% granted (51 of 144). Warning sign if under 25% (fewer than 1 in 4).
    The respondent’s motions to reopen (O), reconsider (FD), administratively close (AC), stay removal (SY), suppress evidence (SP) and place the case on the status docket (PS), since January 20, 2025, granted or denied, whether filed by a lawyer or by the person. Motions to terminate and for voluntary departure are not included. Warning sign when under 25% were granted. Motions to reopen are most of this pile and are denied more often everywhere, so a judge with many of them, for instance after in-absentia orders, will show a lower rate.
  • DHS motions to pretermit asylum (end it without a full hearing)
    Measures how often the judge lets DHS end an asylum claim without a full hearing.
    89% granted (210 of 235). Warning sign if 90% or more.
    DHS motions to pretermit (PM), which ask the judge to end an asylum or withholding claim without a full hearing on the merits, since January 20, 2025, granted or denied. Warning sign when 90% or more were granted. A judge who pretermits on their own motion, without a DHS filing, does not appear here. Pretermission motions were rare before 2025, so there is no earlier rate to compare.
  • Asylum decided on the merits since January 20, 2025
    Measures whether asylum is a real possibility before this judge.
    16% granted (73 of 452). Before: 58% (301 of 519). Warning sign if under 10%.
    Asylum applications this judge decided on the merits since January 20, 2025: granted against denied, one decision per proceeding, dated by the proceeding’s completion; the same definition as the asylum rate at the top of the page, limited to this window. Withdrawn, abandoned and otherwise closed applications are not counted, and neither are grants of withholding or protection under the Convention Against Torture. Warning sign when under 10% were granted. The judge’s rate from January 1, 2021 up to January 20, 2025 is shown beside it for context and does not change the mark.
  • Asylum denials within a year of the Notice to Appear
    Measures how often the judge rushes to deny an asylum case.
    2% of denials (6 of 373) came within a year. Warning sign if 25% or more. Detained cases are left out.
    Asylum denials since January 20, 2025 in proceedings where the person was not detained, one per proceeding, and how many came within 365 days of the Notice to Appear (the charging document’s date to the proceeding’s completion). Detained cases are left out because those dockets move fast by design. Warning sign when 25% or more of the denials came within a year. EOIR’s own expedited dockets can raise a judge’s share, and the records do not show whether the person asked for more time first.
  • Typical bond amount
    Measures whether this judge sets bonds far above what judges set elsewhere.
    Median $10,000 across 38 bonds set; the national median is $7,000. Warning sign if $15,000 or more (double the national median).
    Bonds this judge set since January 20, 2025 (EOIR’s bonds table: decisions that set or adjust an amount, the amount as recorded, the same rows as the “Bond in depth” section). Warning sign when the median is $15,000 or more, double the national median since that date ($7,000). Only the median is published, never the average. Under 20 bonds the row carries the low-sample note.
  • Bonds of twenty-five thousand dollars or more
    Measures how often this judge sets bonds that almost no one can pay.
    0% of bonds set (0 of 38). Warning sign if 25% or more (1 in 4).
    The same bonds set since January 20, 2025, and how many were $25,000 or more. Warning sign when those are 25% or more. Nationally about 4% of bonds set since that date reach that amount.
  • Bond granted when decided on the merits
    Measures whether a detained person has a real chance of release on bond before this judge.
    83% granted (38 of 46). Warning sign if under 20% (fewer than 1 in 5). Requests turned away for lack of jurisdiction are not counted.
    Bond requests this judge decided on the merits since January 20, 2025: granted (amount lowered, release on recognizance, amelioration granted) against denied (no change, no bond, amelioration denied). Moot, withdrawn and no-jurisdiction rulings are left out: since Matter of Yajure Hurtado (BIA, September 2025) judges turn away most requests from people who entered without inspection for lack of jurisdiction, and that follows the Board, not the judge. Warning sign when under 20% were granted. Who still reaches a merits decision changed with that ruling, so this sign is less clean than the two above it.
Continuance requests from respondents’ lawyersFiled with a lawyer already on the case: time to prepare, gather evidence or pursue relief. Requests to find a lawyer are not counted.Sometimes grants
57% 151 of 265 granted
Before January 20, 2025: granted 257 of 299 (86%).
Motions from each side
Respondent’s motionsUsually grants
76% 1,739 of 2,277 granted
DHS’s motionsUsually grants
85% 395 of 466 granted
Respondents’ motions to terminate the case
43% 26 of 61 granted
DHS motions that end a case quickly
Change of venue (transfer to another court)
98% 103 of 105 granted
Dismiss the case at DHS’s requestRespondents often want this too; since May 2025 DHS also uses it to move people into expedited removal. The records don’t say which.
67% 6 of 9 grantedLow sample: 9 rulings
8 of these were people with no lawyer on record; 5 granted.
Pretermit asylum (end it without a full hearing)
89% 210 of 235 granted
Respondents’ appeals to the Board (BIA)Appeals of this judge’s decisions. Motions to reopen filed with the Board itself, bond and interlocutory appeals, and remands only for background checks are not counted.
7%
The Board sent back or reversed 7 of 104 decided appeals (7%). Before the cut-off: 62 of 277 (22%).

How this is counted: motions EOIR logged with a decision of granted or denied (moot and withdrawn motions are left out). Many oral motions are decided on the record without an entry, so these figures count what was logged, not every request made in court. Every rate and label is shown however few rulings it rests on; under 20 rulings it carries a “Low sample” note. Labels: never (none granted), rarely (under 25%), sometimes (under 75%), usually (75% or more), always (every one granted). EOIR data through October 1, 2026. Why these figures matter: No Due Process in Immigration Court System.

38.5%
of asylum claims granted on the merits
Based on 971 asylum decisions (grants + denials) since 2021.
This judge
38.5%
This court
31.8%
National average
28.1%
0%100% granted
In the top 25% of the 961 judges nationally with enough cases to compare.
Grants asylum 13th most often of 32 judges at this court with enough cases to compare.

Does a lawyer matter here?

Asylum grant rate by whether the person had a lawyer on file when the case was decided.
With a lawyerrepresented · 874 decisions since 2021
41.4%
Without a lawyerunrepresented · 97 decisions since 2021
12.4%

Asylum grant rate over time

Each point is that calendar year's grant rate, back to 2015 where the judge was deciding cases — the longer career view. Dashed grey line = current national average (28.1%). Headline rates above use 2021 – today.
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%2016: 0% of 1 decisions · Low sample: 1 decision0%20162017: 45% of 100 decisions45%20172018: 33.2% of 377 decisions33.2%20182019: 35.5% of 459 decisions35.5%20192020: 35.4% of 130 decisions35.4%20202021: 82.2% of 45 decisions · Low sample: 45 decisions82.2%20212022: 75.6% of 135 decisions75.6%20222023: 60.4% of 154 decisions60.4%20232024: 39.6% of 169 decisions39.6%20242025: 22.8% of 254 decisions22.8%20252026 (partial year): 7.9% of 214 decisions7.9%2026*
* 2026 is a partial year (data through 10/01/2026) and is incomplete.

Asylum outcomes by nationality

Of the asylum applications this judge decided on the merits, the share granted, by the applicant's nationality. For people from Guinea, 25.3% means this judge granted asylum in 24 of 95 decisions. Only grants and denials count: withdrawn, abandoned and undecided applications are left out, and a person denied asylum but granted withholding of removal or protection under the Convention Against Torture counts as a denial here. Every rate is shown; one resting on fewer than 20 decisions carries a “Low sample” note. "All judges" is the same measure for every immigration judge in the country, with all their decisions for that nationality added together.
Guinea95 decisions
25.3%
All judges 34.7%
Senegal90 decisions
6.7%
All judges 11.3%
China82 decisions
76.8%
All judges 63.5%
Ecuador81 decisions
13.6%
All judges 12.4%
Honduras56 decisions
53.6%
All judges 16.1%
India55 decisions
40%
All judges 46.7%
El Salvador46 decisions
63%
All judges 24.7%
Ghana46 decisions
52.2%
All judges 44.4%
Show all 64 nationalities
Guatemala42 decisions
31%
All judges 19.6%
Bangladesh37 decisions
56.8%
All judges 57.5%
Burkina Faso32 decisions
43.8%
All judges 52.7%
Peru29 decisions
20.7%
All judges 12.3%
Venezuela27 decisions
29.6%
All judges 30.2%
Mauritania22 decisions
22.7%
All judges 19.9%
AlbaniaLow sample: 16 decisions
75%
All judges 73%
NicaraguaLow sample: 16 decisions
43.8%
All judges 27.4%
ColombiaLow sample: 14 decisions
7.1%
All judges 11.9%
GeorgiaLow sample: 14 decisions
92.9%
All judges 47%
JamaicaLow sample: 14 decisions
21.4%
All judges 18.6%
KosovoLow sample: 14 decisions
71.4%
All judges 69.7%
Dominican RepublicLow sample: 12 decisions
0%
All judges 6.1%
GambiaLow sample: 10 decisions
20%
All judges 31.9%
MexicoLow sample: 10 decisions
10%
All judges 8.2%
PakistanLow sample: 9 decisions
55.6%
All judges 51.3%
RussiaLow sample: 8 decisions
62.5%
All judges 70%
MaliLow sample: 7 decisions
0%
All judges 34.3%
VietnamLow sample: 7 decisions
14.3%
All judges 26.8%
NepalLow sample: 6 decisions
100%
All judges 62.3%
TogoLow sample: 6 decisions
16.7%
All judges 34.7%
HaitiLow sample: 5 decisions
0%
All judges 10.3%
Ivory Coast (Côte d'Ivoire)Low sample: 4 decisions
75%
All judges 51.1%
UkraineLow sample: 4 decisions
100%
All judges 75.5%
Soviet Union (former)Low sample: 4 decisions
100%
All judges 84.5%
UzbekistanLow sample: 4 decisions
75%
All judges 39.3%
BhutanLow sample: 3 decisions
0%
All judges 37.8%
EgyptLow sample: 3 decisions
100%
All judges 53.2%
SingaporeLow sample: 3 decisions
0%
All judges 20.3%
Unknown NationalityLow sample: 2 decisions
100%
All judges 58.2%
AzerbaijanLow sample: 2 decisions
50%
All judges 59.5%
BahamasLow sample: 2 decisions
100%
All judges 7%
BrazilLow sample: 2 decisions
0%
All judges 16.2%
ChadLow sample: 2 decisions
50%
All judges 36.2%
CameroonLow sample: 2 decisions
50%
All judges 58.6%
DominicaLow sample: 2 decisions
0%
All judges 4.6%
NigerLow sample: 2 decisions
0%
All judges 41.2%
PanamaLow sample: 2 decisions
0%
All judges 18.2%
SwazilandLow sample: 2 decisions
100%
All judges 100%Low sample: 7 decisions
YemenLow sample: 2 decisions
0%
All judges 43.8%
BermudaLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 40%
BelarusLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 83.7%
Republic of the CongoLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 47.5%
ChileLow sample: 1 decision
100%
All judges 12.7%
Costa RicaLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 14%
CubaLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 26.4%
Democratic Republic of the CongoLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 50.6%
GermanyLow sample: 1 decision
100%
All judges 25.9%
HollandLow sample: 1 decision
100%
All judges 29.2%
JordanLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 25.6%
KyrgyzstanLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 45.7%
NiueLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 42.9%Low sample: 7 decisions
SerbiaLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 59.6%
SudanLow sample: 1 decision
0%
All judges 43.9%
TajikistanLow sample: 1 decision
100%
All judges 46%
TurkeyLow sample: 1 decision
100%
All judges 53.4%
971 asylum decisions on the merits (grants and denials) since 2021, from 64 nationalities.

Grant rates by type of relief

Share granted among merits decisions for each application type, since 2021.
Asylum
38.5% 971 decisions
Withholding / CAT
4.9% 1,142 decisions
Cancellation — 42B (non-LPR)
78.8% 66 decisions
Cancellation — 42A (LPR)
75% Low sample: 4 decisions
Adjustment of status (245)
92.3% Low sample: 13 decisions
Voluntary departure
97% 99 decisions

Bond decisions

Custody redetermination (bond) rulings since 2021. "Granted" means the judge lowered the bond, ordered release on recognizance, or otherwise granted the request.
82.6%
Bond requests granted
Low sample: 46 decisions
$10,000
Median bond when set
38 bonds with amounts
0%
Released on own recognizance
0% of grants
Also 19 requests denied as moot (nothing was left to decide), counted apart and left out of the grant rate.
This judge 82.6%
Buffalo, NY, where these bonds were heard: 57.2% · median $10,000 (2,057 bond decisions)
National 50.3% · median $7,000

Bond in depth: amounts and outcomes by year

Every bond (custody redetermination) decision this judge entered since 2021, by calendar year of the decision (January to December; the last year runs to September 2026, when EOIR's data ends). Amounts are the bond the judge set when lowering it, raising it or granting amelioration, exactly as recorded. EOIR does not reliably record DHS's starting amount, so “lowered”, “raised” and “no change” come from the judge's decision code.
This judge 154 bond decisions · 38 with an amount set · median $10,000
Buffalo median $10,000 (1,374 amounts set)

Amounts set, by range

Bonds this judge set, by amount range, with this court’s share
RangeThis judgeShareThis court
Under $1,50000%0.22%
$1,500 (statutory minimum)00%2.4%
$1,501–$5,000411%18%
$5,001–$10,0002155%40%
$10,001–$25,0001334%34%
Over $25,00000%5.7%
Total38100%100%
The ranges follow the amounts judges actually set: $1,500 is the statutory minimum (INA § 236(a)(2)(A)), and $5,000 and $10,000 are the two most common amounts nationwide, so each sits whole at the top of its range.

Outcomes by year

This judge’s bond decisions by outcome and calendar year
Outcome20252026*All years
Granted
Bond lowered221638
Denied
No bond set268
Not counted in the grant rate (including requests denied as moot)
Denied as moot11819
No jurisdiction (J)24630
Request withdrawn352459
Bond decisions8470154
Amounts set221638
Median amount$7,500$15,000$10,000
Median at the court these bonds were heard at$7,500$10,000$10,000
Amounts set, by range
Under $1,500000
$1,500 (statutory minimum)000
$1,501–$5,000404
$5,001–$10,00016521
$10,001–$25,00021113
Over $25,000000
* 2026 is a partial year: the data runs to September 2026.

Every amount set

Every bond amount this judge set, as recorded, by calendar year
Amount20252026*Total
$5,000404
$7,500909
$10,0007512
$15,000167
$20,000156
Total221638

In the courtroom

Languages in the courtroom

Spanish67%
Wolof5.8%
English4.8%
Mandarin2.3%
Haitian Creole2.0%
Language on the case record, 5,956 completed cases. An interpreter is provided by the court at no cost.

Custody

Detained when decided4.4%
Released from detention before the decision9.5%
Never detained86%
Custody status at completion, 5,956 cases.

Courts where this judge has decided cases

Hearing locations for cases this judge completed since 2021, by number of decisions. Many judges hear cases from more than one court (detained facilities, video dockets, or reassignments).
New York, NY · home court
5,601 (94%)
225 (3.8%)
98 (1.6%)
7 (0.12%)
3 (0.05%)

If you have a hearing before this judge

The figures on this page describe past decisions, not yours. What you can change is how prepared you arrive: the right application filed on time, the evidence the judge will expect, and someone beside you who knows this courtroom.