Judges furthest from their own court

Where one judge's asylum rate sits far from the rate of the court around them. Ranked by the part of the gap the evidence supports, so a small docket cannot outrank a large one on a number that might be noise; judges whose range still overlaps their court's rate are left out entirely.

#JudgeCourtAppointed underAsylum decisionsGrantedGap from court
1Noel A Brennan (former judge)New York — Broadway, NYGeorge W. Bush54748187.9% vs 31.8%
2Olivia L Cassin (fired 2025-11)New York — Broadway, NYBarack Obama58050486.9% vs 31.8%
3Ravit R HalperinSacramento, CADonald Trump6938412.1% vs 63.5%
4Stephanie ArracheWest Valley, UTDonald Trump12743.1% vs 55.2%
5Douglas B Schoppert (former judge)New York — Broadway, NYBill Clinton40433582.9% vs 31.8%
6Maureen O'Sullivan (former judge)Boston, MABarack Obama89682992.5% vs 43.7%
7Andrew ScafidiConcord, CADonald Trump13600.0% vs 49.2%
8Julina SchaefferLas Vegas, NVDonald Trump3600.0% vs 56.0%
9Lauren M BlackConcord, CADonald Trump12400.0% vs 49.2%
10Eric WangConcord, CADonald Trump10800.0% vs 49.2%
11Sameer Ahmed (former judge)Chelmsford (CHE), MAJoe Biden39532883.0% vs 33.3%
12Samantha Begovich (former judge)San Francisco, CADonald Trump2934515.4% vs 65.5%
13Ellaine L GossConcord, CADonald Trump8500.0% vs 49.2%
14Laurie SamuelsNew York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump10400.0% vs 48.0%
15Julie L NelsonSan Francisco, CABarack Obama69712818.4% vs 65.5%
16Shifra Rubin (former judge)Newark, NJBarack Obama58638365.4% vs 17.4%
17James KitchenNew York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump13010.8% vs 48.0%
18Thomas J Mulligan (former judge)New York — Varick Street, NYGeorge W. Bush48339481.6% vs 34.2%
19Stephen F Keane (former judge)Concord, CADonald Trump6200.0% vs 49.2%
20Watson BerichNew York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump6600.0% vs 48.0%
21Robert MoskowNew York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump6600.0% vs 48.0%
22Linda HristovaNew York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump29093.1% vs 48.0%
23Christopher Day (fired 2025-12)Pearsall, TXDonald Trump44100.0% vs 10.0%
24E. Mark Barcus (former judge)Dallas, TXBarack Obama624064.5% vs 11.3%
25Marla GillmanNew York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump7011.4% vs 48.0%
26Adam R MorrisConcord, CADonald Trump10943.7% vs 49.2%
27Raisa Cohen (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NYBarack Obama45441391.0% vs 48.0%
28Karen NazaireNew York — Federal Plaza, NYJoe Biden813516.3% vs 48.0%
29Christopher CusmanoNew York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump10332.9% vs 48.0%
30Matthew PemberConcord, CADonald Trump3600.0% vs 49.2%
31Bayleigh PettigrewSacramento, CADonald Trump65913.8% vs 63.5%
32Taylor GillespieBoston, MADonald Trump6500.0% vs 43.7%
33Frank A SeminerioSan Francisco, CAJoe Biden2,92375525.8% vs 65.5%
34Shawn J AbrahamChicago, ILDonald Trump17000.0% vs 40.2%
35Vivienne E Gordon-Uruakpa (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NYGeorge W. Bush69561588.5% vs 48.0%
36Lawrence O Burman (former judge)Annandale (WAS), VABill Clinton67049874.3% vs 33.0%
37Gita Vahid-Tehrani (former judge)Los Angeles — West, CAGeorge W. Bush947175.5% vs 28.2%
38Patricia W WalterBoston, MADonald Trump5900.0% vs 43.7%
39Louis J LubaNew York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump3300.0% vs 48.0%
40Rebecca J Walters (former judge)Annandale (WAS), VAJoe Biden564682.1% vs 33.0%
41Evan Schultz (former judge)Hyattsville, MDJoe Biden1119182.0% vs 37.7%
42Tanzania JaysuraBoston, MADonald Trump6611.5% vs 43.7%
43Tiesha PealNew York — Federal Plaza, NYJoe Biden2,07622811.0% vs 48.0%
44Jean M KilkerNew York — Federal Plaza, NYDonald Trump11986.7% vs 48.0%
45James GloberWest Valley, UTDonald Trump1672414.4% vs 55.2%
46Glen Ray Hines Jr. (former judge)Dallas, TXDonald Trump392461.5% vs 11.3%
47Mimi Tsankov (former judge)New York — Federal Plaza, NYGeorge W. Bush65355885.5% vs 48.0%
48Sebastian T Patti (former judge)Chicago, ILDonald Trump44334978.8% vs 40.2%
49John Henderson (former judge)Hyattsville, MDDonald Trump222090.9% vs 37.7%
50Maria Lurye (fired 2025-12)New York — Federal Plaza, NYBarack Obama77866285.1% vs 48.0%

Decisions from 2021 through 10/01/2026. Showing 50 of 845 that qualified. Past patterns, not predictions — every case turns on its own facts and law.