Judges furthest from their own court
Where one judge's asylum rate sits far from the rate of the court around them. Ranked by the part of the gap the evidence supports, so a small docket cannot outrank a large one on a number that might be noise; judges whose range still overlaps their court's rate are left out entirely.
| # | Judge | Court | Appointed under | Asylum decisions | Granted | Gap from court |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Noel A Brennan (former judge) | New York — Broadway, NY | George W. Bush | 547 | 481 | 87.9% vs 31.8% |
| 2 | Olivia L Cassin (fired 2025-11) | New York — Broadway, NY | Barack Obama | 580 | 504 | 86.9% vs 31.8% |
| 3 | Ravit R Halperin | Sacramento, CA | Donald Trump | 693 | 84 | 12.1% vs 63.5% |
| 4 | Stephanie Arrache | West Valley, UT | Donald Trump | 127 | 4 | 3.1% vs 55.2% |
| 5 | Douglas B Schoppert (former judge) | New York — Broadway, NY | Bill Clinton | 404 | 335 | 82.9% vs 31.8% |
| 6 | Maureen O'Sullivan (former judge) | Boston, MA | Barack Obama | 896 | 829 | 92.5% vs 43.7% |
| 7 | Andrew Scafidi | Concord, CA | Donald Trump | 136 | 0 | 0.0% vs 49.2% |
| 8 | Julina Schaeffer | Las Vegas, NV | Donald Trump | 36 | 0 | 0.0% vs 56.0% |
| 9 | Lauren M Black | Concord, CA | Donald Trump | 124 | 0 | 0.0% vs 49.2% |
| 10 | Eric Wang | Concord, CA | Donald Trump | 108 | 0 | 0.0% vs 49.2% |
| 11 | Sameer Ahmed (former judge) | Chelmsford (CHE), MA | Joe Biden | 395 | 328 | 83.0% vs 33.3% |
| 12 | Samantha Begovich (former judge) | San Francisco, CA | Donald Trump | 293 | 45 | 15.4% vs 65.5% |
| 13 | Ellaine L Goss | Concord, CA | Donald Trump | 85 | 0 | 0.0% vs 49.2% |
| 14 | Laurie Samuels | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Donald Trump | 104 | 0 | 0.0% vs 48.0% |
| 15 | Julie L Nelson | San Francisco, CA | Barack Obama | 697 | 128 | 18.4% vs 65.5% |
| 16 | Shifra Rubin (former judge) | Newark, NJ | Barack Obama | 586 | 383 | 65.4% vs 17.4% |
| 17 | James Kitchen | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Donald Trump | 130 | 1 | 0.8% vs 48.0% |
| 18 | Thomas J Mulligan (former judge) | New York — Varick Street, NY | George W. Bush | 483 | 394 | 81.6% vs 34.2% |
| 19 | Stephen F Keane (former judge) | Concord, CA | Donald Trump | 62 | 0 | 0.0% vs 49.2% |
| 20 | Watson Berich | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Donald Trump | 66 | 0 | 0.0% vs 48.0% |
| 21 | Robert Moskow | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Donald Trump | 66 | 0 | 0.0% vs 48.0% |
| 22 | Linda Hristova | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Donald Trump | 290 | 9 | 3.1% vs 48.0% |
| 23 | Christopher Day (fired 2025-12) | Pearsall, TX | Donald Trump | 4 | 4 | 100.0% vs 10.0% |
| 24 | E. Mark Barcus (former judge) | Dallas, TX | Barack Obama | 62 | 40 | 64.5% vs 11.3% |
| 25 | Marla Gillman | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Donald Trump | 70 | 1 | 1.4% vs 48.0% |
| 26 | Adam R Morris | Concord, CA | Donald Trump | 109 | 4 | 3.7% vs 49.2% |
| 27 | Raisa Cohen (former judge) | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Barack Obama | 454 | 413 | 91.0% vs 48.0% |
| 28 | Karen Nazaire | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Joe Biden | 813 | 51 | 6.3% vs 48.0% |
| 29 | Christopher Cusmano | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Donald Trump | 103 | 3 | 2.9% vs 48.0% |
| 30 | Matthew Pember | Concord, CA | Donald Trump | 36 | 0 | 0.0% vs 49.2% |
| 31 | Bayleigh Pettigrew | Sacramento, CA | Donald Trump | 65 | 9 | 13.8% vs 63.5% |
| 32 | Taylor Gillespie | Boston, MA | Donald Trump | 65 | 0 | 0.0% vs 43.7% |
| 33 | Frank A Seminerio | San Francisco, CA | Joe Biden | 2,923 | 755 | 25.8% vs 65.5% |
| 34 | Shawn J Abraham | Chicago, IL | Donald Trump | 170 | 0 | 0.0% vs 40.2% |
| 35 | Vivienne E Gordon-Uruakpa (former judge) | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | George W. Bush | 695 | 615 | 88.5% vs 48.0% |
| 36 | Lawrence O Burman (former judge) | Annandale (WAS), VA | Bill Clinton | 670 | 498 | 74.3% vs 33.0% |
| 37 | Gita Vahid-Tehrani (former judge) | Los Angeles — West, CA | George W. Bush | 94 | 71 | 75.5% vs 28.2% |
| 38 | Patricia W Walter | Boston, MA | Donald Trump | 59 | 0 | 0.0% vs 43.7% |
| 39 | Louis J Luba | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Donald Trump | 33 | 0 | 0.0% vs 48.0% |
| 40 | Rebecca J Walters (former judge) | Annandale (WAS), VA | Joe Biden | 56 | 46 | 82.1% vs 33.0% |
| 41 | Evan Schultz (former judge) | Hyattsville, MD | Joe Biden | 111 | 91 | 82.0% vs 37.7% |
| 42 | Tanzania Jaysura | Boston, MA | Donald Trump | 66 | 1 | 1.5% vs 43.7% |
| 43 | Tiesha Peal | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Joe Biden | 2,076 | 228 | 11.0% vs 48.0% |
| 44 | Jean M Kilker | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Donald Trump | 119 | 8 | 6.7% vs 48.0% |
| 45 | James Glober | West Valley, UT | Donald Trump | 167 | 24 | 14.4% vs 55.2% |
| 46 | Glen Ray Hines Jr. (former judge) | Dallas, TX | Donald Trump | 39 | 24 | 61.5% vs 11.3% |
| 47 | Mimi Tsankov (former judge) | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | George W. Bush | 653 | 558 | 85.5% vs 48.0% |
| 48 | Sebastian T Patti (former judge) | Chicago, IL | Donald Trump | 443 | 349 | 78.8% vs 40.2% |
| 49 | John Henderson (former judge) | Hyattsville, MD | Donald Trump | 22 | 20 | 90.9% vs 37.7% |
| 50 | Maria Lurye (fired 2025-12) | New York — Federal Plaza, NY | Barack Obama | 778 | 662 | 85.1% vs 48.0% |
Decisions from 2021 through 10/01/2026. Showing 50 of 845 that qualified. Past patterns, not predictions — every case turns on its own facts and law.